The fourth episode of On Cinema at the Cinema's sixteenth season is a special black-and-white episode and the last to be shot at the HEI Network ESA Campus. The episode features host New Heidecker and guest Gregg Turkington reviewing Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere, Regretting You, and The Watchers (2025, not to be confused with 2024's The Watchers).

In the episode, Gregg returns the movie props intended for the scrapped pepboys film to G. Amato with stipulations. Following the reviews, New announces that starting with the next episode, On Cinema at the Cinema will tape in a new studio with a live audience and an “entirely new format”, and gives a health update following a talk with riogenesis customer support. For ”Popcorn Classics”, Gregg selects The Wackiest Wagon Train in the West, and notes how they turned “garbage into gold” by turning 4 episodes of a TV show into a movie.

Springsteen: Deliver Me from Nowhere (2025, 119 mins.)
New: 5 bags of popcorn
Gregg: 4 bags of popcorn

Regretting You (2025, 116 mins.)
New: 4 bags of popcorn, 1 cup of soda, OSCAR PICK
Gregg: 5 bags of popcorn

The Watchers (2025, 124 mins.)
New: no score given
Gregg: 5 bags of popcorn, an oblong pillow

TBD

• Gregg's clothing this episode includes a hat for Jumanji (1995, 104 mins.) and a shirt for Deck of Cards (2022, 45 mins.). Both have “: The Movie” stickers applied under the logos, converting the titles to Jumanji: The Movie and Deck of Cards: The Movie respectively.
• While the footage is shown in black and white, the intro, graphics, and movie footage are still in full color, save for the “Popcorn Classics” intro.
• Gregg unusually gives the Popcorn Classic a rating, of 5 bags of popcorn. The editing team add on the appropriate graphics in the process.

• HEI Network (video, subscription required)