On Cinema After Cinema (listed as On Cinema at the Cinema Season 5 Episode 7.1) is a bonus short episode filmed immediately after S5E07 and aired on August 13, 2014. Tim Heidecker and Gregg Turkington occupy their usual spots as host and co-host.

The episode features a Tim's Mailbag segment, in which Tim reads fan mail written to him via Gregg. All of the letters he reads in this episode praise Tim's new show, Decker, and for some reason, seem to be ecstatic about Gregg, urging Tim to include him more.

Tim and Gregg expressed hope that On Cinema After Cinema would become a regular addendum to the standard episodes, but this is so far the only iteration. Regular post-episode content would not come about until the Encore postscripts to On Cinema On Demand.