During the course of On Cinema at the Cinema, blue cards have been used to assist host Tim Heidecker. They are plain blue cards with the names, cast and crew, and synopsis of the movies being discussed that episode. They have been present since the first episode of the show.

Starting Season 12, due to the move of the show to the HEI Network, the blue cards were printed with a monochrome HEI Network logo on their back.

During Season 13, to fit the aesthetic of the Amato Banquet Hall, the cards were no longer blue, but white, with a colored HEI Network logo printed on their back.

On On Cinema On Demand, the cards are once again blue, and have a HEI Network sticker on their back.

During joeyinterview, Kaili Amato used her own blue cards with an Amato Group sticker on their back.